Local Guides

    Black Tooth Brewing Sheridan Winter Taproom Guide for Cold Nights

    November 18, 2026 · 6 min read · Wyo Stays Journal

    Black Tooth Brewing in Sheridan Wyoming runs a warm, low-key taproom through winter, with seasonal dark beers, shorter but reliable weekday hours, and a rotating lineup of trivia and live music nights that give downtown Sheridan somewhere to go once the temperature drops below freezing.

    Wyo Stays guests staying downtown often end up here first. Walk in on a February evening and the front windows are steamed up, the concrete floor is doing its job holding heat from the brewhouse next door, and there's usually a stout or a porter on tap that wasn't around in July. It's one of the few spots in town where a Tuesday night in the dead of winter still feels like something's happening.

    Key Takeaways

    • Black Tooth's winter lineup leans into stouts, porters, and darker seasonal releases not on tap in summer
    • Winter taproom hours run shorter — typically closed Monday, open afternoon through evening the rest of the week
    • Trivia nights and occasional live music fill the taproom on weeknights through the cold months
    • The taproom is walkable from most downtown Sheridan lodging and rentals
    • Sheridan's brewery is a founding stop on any downtown Sheridan bar crawl, winter or summer

    What Makes Black Tooth Brewing Sheridan Winter Different?

    The beer list shifts noticeably — expect stouts, porters, and occasionally a barrel-aged release that wouldn't make sense on a hot July afternoon. The vibe shifts too: summer brings a busier patio crowd, while winter turns the taproom into more of a locals' living room, with regulars claiming the same stools and staff who know their order before they ask.

    Sheridan's brewery scene isn't large, which means Black Tooth's taproom carries more weight in winter than it does in July, when there are more outdoor options competing for attention. Once the patio closes for the season, the indoor bar becomes the default gathering spot — the concrete and brick interior holds heat well, and the brewhouse itself throws off enough warmth that you'll often see people shed a jacket within a few minutes of walking in from single-digit temperatures outside.

    What Are Black Tooth Brewing's Winter Hours?

    Winter hours typically run shorter than the summer schedule, often closed Mondays with afternoon-to-evening hours Tuesday through Sunday. Hours shift seasonally and around holidays, so check the Black Tooth Brewing website directly before a visit rather than relying on last summer's schedule.

    Holiday weeks compress hours further — expect earlier closing times around Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year's as staff scale back for the season. If a visit is timed around a specific holiday, calling ahead or checking the brewery's social media the same week is worth the two minutes it takes, since posted hours online don't always update fast enough to catch a last-minute holiday closure.

    What Events Happen at the Taproom During Winter?

    A black tooth brewing sheridan winter visit almost always includes trivia night, the season's staple, usually running weekly and drawing a mixed crowd of regulars and visiting families. Live music shows up more sporadically in the colder months than summer's steady outdoor concert schedule, so watch the brewery's event calendar if a specific show or night matters to your trip. Holiday-week visits sometimes bring special release beers timed to Christmas or New Year's.

    Trivia teams tend to skew local, so don't expect an easy win as an out-of-towner — regulars know the format and the categories tend to favor Wyoming and Western history along with the usual pop-culture rounds. It's still a fun, low-stakes way to spend a cold weeknight, and staff are generally happy to fold visiting guests into an open table if your group is smaller than the standard team size. Check the brewery's Instagram or website closer to your trip for the current week's schedule, since event nights occasionally shift around holidays and slow winter weeks.

    Is Black Tooth Worth Visiting If You're Not a Big Beer Drinker?

    Yes — the taproom serves food from rotating local vendors or food trucks depending on the season, and it's as much a place to warm up and sit somewhere lively as it is a beer destination. Non-drinkers can still enjoy the atmosphere, the games, and the fact that it's one of the few reliably open, reliably warm spots downtown on a slow winter weeknight.

    It's also one of the more affordable social outings in town during a season when a lot of Sheridan's other winter draws — skiing at Antelope Butte, snowmobiling in the Bighorns — require more gear and planning. A taproom visit is a low-commitment way to fill an evening when the roads are icy or the group just wants to stay close to downtown lodging rather than driving anywhere after dark.

    CategoryWinter Detail (estimate where noted)
    Typical winter hoursClosed Mon; Tue-Sun afternoon-evening (confirm current schedule)
    Signature winter beersStout, porter, seasonal dark releases
    Weekly eventTrivia night (day varies by season)
    Distance from downtown Sheridan lodgingWalkable, under 10 minutes on foot

    Hours and events change seasonally — always confirm current details on Black Tooth's own site or social pages before planning a visit around them.

    Parking downtown is easier to find in winter than during the busy summer festival season, and most street spots within a block or two are free after 6pm. If snow is falling, give yourself a few extra minutes — downtown crews clear the main routes quickly, but side streets can stay slick longer, and Sheridan winters are not the place to rush a parallel park.

    Black Tooth's taproom is one of the first places I send winter guests who ask "where is everybody?" It's proof Sheridan doesn't shut down just because it's cold — it just moves indoors. — Dalton Goodyear, Wyo Stays

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Q: Is Black Tooth Brewing open year-round? A: Yes, Black Tooth operates year-round with adjusted winter hours — expect shorter days and a closed Monday during the colder months.

    Q: Does Black Tooth Brewing serve food? A: The taproom typically partners with rotating food trucks or vendors rather than running its own kitchen, so food availability can vary by day — check ahead if a meal is part of the plan.

    Q: Is Black Tooth family-friendly? A: Yes, the taproom generally welcomes families during daytime and early evening hours, though it leans more adult-oriented during trivia and later evening events.

    Q: How far is Black Tooth Brewing from downtown Sheridan rentals? A: Most downtown Sheridan rentals are within a 5-10 minute walk, making it an easy stop without needing to drive or find winter parking.

    Sheridan Wyoming's winter social scene runs through spots like Black Tooth, and staying close to downtown makes all of it easier to reach on foot rather than navigating icy side streets after dark. Book Direct — No Channel Fees on a downtown Sheridan rental through book.wyostays.com and walk to the taproom instead of driving on icy roads.

    As a licensed, insured Wyoming vacation rental brokerage, Wyo Stays can match you with a downtown property close to Black Tooth and the rest of Sheridan's winter bar scene. Book direct at book.wyostays.com — skip the OTA fees — and browse listings at wyostays.com before your next Sheridan winter trip.