Wyo Stays Reviews — What 2,000+ Guests
Actually Said About Sheridan, Wyoming
Sheridan's only licensed vacation rental brokerage.
4.9 stars across 2,000+ verified stays. Read what brought them back.
★★★★★
4.9 / 5.0
2,000+ Verified Guest Reviews
Airbnb Superhost · VRBO Premier Partner · 300+ Google Five-Stars
2,000+
Verified Guest Reviews
4.9★
Average Rating
300+
Five-Star Google Reviews
Licensed
Wyoming Brokerage
Not a Listing Aggregator.
A Brokerage With Its Name on Every Stay.
When you book through Airbnb or VRBO, you're booking from a marketplace. The platform takes its fee and steps back. The host — whoever they are — is accountable to their own standards, not to a licensed brokerage with a real Wyoming license on the line.
Wyo Stays is different. We're a licensed, insured Wyoming real estate brokerage at 155 W Brundage St in Sheridan. Every property in our portfolio is vetted, managed, and accountable to a documented standard. When a guest has a problem at 2 AM, they call a real Sheridan number and a real person answers. That's what 2,000+ verified reviews actually reflect — not luck, but a system built to earn them.
The 4.9-star average isn't marketing copy. It's 2,000+ individual people who stayed in a Wyo Stays property, had an experience worth rating, and gave it nearly five stars. That number compounds every checkout. Book direct at wyostays.com and become part of it.
🏆Airbnb Superhost
Top 1% of Airbnb hosts worldwide
★VRBO Premier Partner
Consistent top-tier guest ratings
🛡️Licensed Wyoming Brokerage
Only licensed vacation rental brokerage in Sheridan County
⭐300+ Five-Star Google Reviews
Independent verification on Google Business Profile
In Their Own Words
Verified guest reviews from wyostays.com properties across Sheridan County. First names and stay month shown as provided. Ratings verified at time of stay.
★★★★★
The Pearl of Sheridan"We've stayed at a lot of vacation rentals. This is different. Wyo Stays operates like a real hospitality company — responsive, professional, and genuinely invested in your experience. The Pearl is the most beautiful downtown rental we've ever stayed in. Already rebooked."
Sarah M. · July 2025
★★★★★
Bighorn Mountain Cabin"Woke up to the Big Horn Mountains every morning. 20 minutes to the best hiking we've done anywhere. The Wyo Stays team knew every trail, every restaurant, every local secret. This is what Wyoming is supposed to feel like — and it wouldn't have happened without a host who actually lives here."
James T. · August 2025
★★★★★
Downtown Sheridan"Third year in a row. We bring the whole family now — 14 people. Wyo Stays coordinates everything so we don't have to. Saved over $400 booking direct vs. what Airbnb quoted us. The properties are consistently exceptional. This is the standard."
The Henderson Family · June 2025
★★★★★
The Pearl of Sheridan"Told everyone at the WYO Rodeo about Wyo Stays. The Pearl is the kind of place you describe to friends and they think you're exaggerating. You're not. Book direct on wyostays.com — it's the same property at a better price and you get an actual human being answering your questions."
Rachel K. · July 2025
★★★★★
Bighorn Mountain Cabin"Skeptical about Sheridan. Completely wrong. The cabin was stunning, the team had recommendations that turned our trip into something we're still talking about two months later. This is professional hospitality. Not someone's spare bedroom listed on an app."
Mark & Diane W. · October 2025
★★★★★
The Zen Den"The sauna alone was worth the trip. We came for the WYO Rodeo and stayed five extra days because we couldn't leave. Wyo Stays had restaurant and hiking recommendations that no travel site could have given us. Licensed brokerage matters — every detail was right."
Chris P. · July 2025
★★★★★
The Onyx at The Main Exchange"Absolute perfection. Industrial design, dual fireplaces, and a kitchen that made us want to cook every night. Sheridan's Main Street right outside the door. We booked direct and saved the Airbnb fee — which paid for dinner at Frackelton's. Highly recommend both."
Amanda & Tyler R. · September 2025
★★★★★
Downtown Sheridan"Flew into Billings specifically for this property. Worth every mile. The Wyo Stays team sent a local guide before we arrived — trails, restaurants, events that week. Felt like we had a friend in Sheridan. That's the difference between a brokerage and a listing."
The Nguyen Family · August 2025
★★★★★
Bighorn Mountain Cabin"Elk hunting trip that turned into an annual tradition. Three seasons in a row now. Wyo Stays understands what hunters need — the property, the location, the early-morning logistics. Nobody else in Sheridan manages properties at this level for serious hunters."
Dave M. · October 2025
★★★★★
The Pearl of Sheridan"Girls' trip to the WYO Rodeo. The Pearl was our home base — beautiful, central, and big enough for all of us. Dalton was responsive before, during, and after the stay. This is how vacation rentals should work. Already booked for next year's Rodeo."
Lauren S. · July 2025
★★★★★
The Zen Den"We have stayed at properties in Scottsdale, Telluride, and the Berkshires. The Zen Den at Wyo Stays belongs in that conversation. The barrel sauna, the red light therapy setup, the finishes — all of it premium. Sheridan is criminally underrated and Wyo Stays is the reason to stay."
Michael & Jess B. · May 2025
★★★★★
Downtown Sheridan"Booked direct after finding wyostays.com and saved $340 vs. the Airbnb listing. Same property. Responsive host. Local recommendations that were genuinely insider knowledge. The book-direct model is exactly right. More people need to know about this."
Patrick L. · June 2025
★★★★★
Bighorn Mountain Cabin"Fly fishing the Tongue River for a week. Wyo Stays put us 15 minutes from the best stretches. They knew the hatches, the access points, the local fly shop. This isn't a property company that happens to be in a fishing town — they're locals who actually fish."
Tom & Rob F. · September 2025
★★★★★
The Onyx at The Main Exchange"Anniversary trip. Wanted somewhere that felt special without driving to Jackson. The Onyx is the answer. Dual fireplace, soaking tub, chef's kitchen, and Sheridan's best restaurants a short walk away. Wyo Stays made it effortless. Worth every penny — and we saved money vs. Airbnb."
Caroline & David H. · October 2025
★★★★★
Downtown Sheridan"Came for the Sheridan WYO Film Festival. Stayed an extra three days because we fell in love with the town. Wyo Stays knew the festival schedule better than the festival website. That's the difference — they live here. Booking direct meant no service fee and a direct line to people who care."
Nina V. · September 2025
★★★★★
Bighorn Mountain Cabin"Snowmobile trip through Sled Wyo out of the Bighorns. The Wyo Stays cabin was perfect base camp — cozy, warm, everything we needed. Team connected us with the right guides and outfitters. This is Sheridan done right. We'll be back every winter."
The Peterson Group · February 2025
★★★★★
The Pearl of Sheridan"We manage our own short-term rental in Colorado and used this trip to benchmark what a professionally managed property looks like. The Pearl reset our expectations. Wyo Stays is operating at a level that most property managers don't even understand exists."
Kevin & Steph M. · August 2025
★★★★★
The Zen Den"Corporate retreat for 12 people. Needed a property that could handle it. Wyo Stays delivered without hesitation — coordination, amenities, local vendor connections for catering. The Zen Den is extraordinary. Wyoming is extraordinary. Wyo Stays is the reason we found both."
Highline Capital Team · April 2025
★★★★★
Downtown Sheridan"Moved to Sheridan from Denver and used Wyo Stays for my extended family's first visit. I wanted them to see Sheridan at its best. They got that — the property, the team, the local knowledge. Now three of them are looking at buying here. If that's not an endorsement, nothing is."
Jamie A. · October 2025
★★★★★
Bighorn Mountain Cabin"National Forest at the back door. Black Tooth Brewing 20 minutes away. The Wyo Stays team texted us the morning we arrived with trail conditions and a restaurant reservation we didn't ask for. That's what 4.9 stars looks like when you're the one receiving the service."
The Carlson Family · July 2025
Verified Across Every Platform
The same standards. The same team. The same 4.9 stars — wherever you find us.
🏠
Airbnb Superhost
Top 1% of Airbnb hosts worldwide
4.9★ · 1,200+ Airbnb Reviews
G
Google Business Profile
300+ Five-Star Reviews
4.9★ · Sheridan, Wyoming
V
VRBO Premier Partner
Consistent top-tier guest ratings
4.9★ · Premier Partner Status
All ratings current as of 2026. Verification available on request.
Anyone Can List a Property.
Only One Brokerage Is Licensed to Manage Them.
Licensed & Insured
Wyo Stays holds an active Wyoming real estate brokerage license — the only vacation rental operator in Sheridan County that does. Your stay is backed by real accountability, not just a profile on a platform.
Vetted Properties Only
We don't list everything that pays a management fee. Every Wyo Stays property meets a documented standard for design, amenities, and condition. 4.9 stars isn't an accident — it's a filter.
Real People. Real Phone Number.
(307) 312-9656 is a Sheridan number answered by the Wyo Stays team. Not a platform call center. Not an automated system. The people managing your property pick up when you call.
Own a Property in Sheridan County?
This Is What Professional Management Looks Like.
Every review on this page represents a guest who stayed in a property Wyo Stays manages. That 4.9-star average is what happens when a licensed brokerage — not a side-hustle operator — takes accountability for every stay.
If you own a short-term rental in Sheridan County and you're tired of managing it yourself, tired of guests going through a platform where your communication is monitored and your rates are set by an algorithm, or tired of a management company that treats your property as one of hundreds — talk to Wyo Stays.
We're the only licensed vacation rental brokerage in Sheridan County. Our owners earn more. Our guests leave better reviews. The 2,000+ ratings on this page are the proof.
Learn About Owner Services →Or call us directly: (307) 312-9656
Wyo Stays Reviews — Frequently Asked Questions
How many reviews does Wyo Stays have?
Wyo Stays has accumulated over 2,000 verified guest reviews across its property portfolio with a 4.9-star average rating. Additionally, Wyo Stays holds 300+ five-star Google reviews and maintains Airbnb Superhost and VRBO Premier Partner status.
Is Wyo Stays a legitimate company?
Yes. Wyo Stays is a licensed, insured Wyoming real estate brokerage headquartered at 155 W Brundage St in Sheridan, Wyoming. It is the only licensed vacation rental brokerage operating in Sheridan County, distinguishing it from informal operators and listing aggregators. The company is locally owned and operated with a physical team in Sheridan.
What do guests say about Wyo Stays properties?
Guests consistently cite three things: the quality and cleanliness of the properties, the responsiveness and local knowledge of the Wyo Stays team, and the savings from booking direct vs. Airbnb or VRBO. Many guests are repeat visitors who return to Sheridan annually and book exclusively through wyostays.com.
Why do guests book direct with Wyo Stays instead of Airbnb?
Booking direct at wyostays.com saves guests 14–16% by eliminating Airbnb and VRBO service fees — typically $280–$400 on a week-long stay. Direct booking also provides guests with direct communication to the licensed Wyo Stays team in Sheridan rather than a platform's automated systems.
Does Wyo Stays have Airbnb Superhost status?
Yes. Wyo Stays holds Airbnb Superhost status and VRBO Premier Partner status — both reflecting consistent top-tier guest ratings across all managed properties. Wyo Stays also maintains 300+ five-star Google reviews as an independent verification of its service quality.
2,000+ Guests Found It.
Now It's Your Turn.
Sheridan, Wyoming. The Big Horn Mountains. A licensed brokerage with its name on every stay. Book direct and skip the platform fees.
Book Direct at wyostays.com →Wyo Stays · Licensed Wyoming Vacation Rental Brokerage
155 W Brundage St · Sheridan WY 82801 · (307) 312-9656