Navigating the Sheridan Rental Market: Wyo Stays’ Commitment Through Changing Times

November 14, 2023

As the leaves turn and we embrace the final months of 2023, it's an opportune time for us at Wyo Stays to provide a market update for our valued clients. Our mission is to keep you informed, maintain your properties at peak market value, and explore opportunities for increased earnings and cost savings, even during challenging economic times.

Rustic yet modern office of a Wyoming property management company, featuring wooden panels, scenic Wyoming landscapes, a sturdy wooden desk with a computer, and leather seating area, overlooking picturesque mountains and fields, embodying a blend of professionalism and Wyoming charm.

The Current State of Sheridan's Rental Market

The Sheridan rental market has seen some notable changes over the past year. As of September 2023, the median rent for available properties in Sheridan is $1,475, a slight decrease from previous months but still robust​​. For a more detailed picture, the median rent for a two-bedroom property now stands at $1,475, significantly higher than the average of $868 observed between 2017 and 2021​​. 

These figures highlight a vibrant and evolving market, one where staying informed and proactive is key to success.

Wyo Stays: Your Partner in Prosperity

In these dynamic times, Wyo Stays stands as a beacon of stability and innovation for our clients. 

Here's how we're making a difference:

Market Trend Analysis: We constantly monitor market fluctuations, ensuring your properties are priced competitively to attract tenants while maximizing your returns.

Property Maintenance and Upkeep: A well-maintained property is a profitable one. We handle all maintenance aspects, ensuring your investments remain in top condition, attracting quality tenants and higher rents.

Proactive Strategies for Vacancies: When long-term rentals experience longer vacancy periods, we don't just wait for tenants to come to us. We actively engage in outreach programs and rigorous applicant follow-up campaigns to fill these vacancies promptly.

Boosting Short-term Rental Visibility: For our vacation rental clients, slow periods don't mean stagnant income. We implement targeted advertising and collaborate with local businesses to increase visibility and bookings.

Community and Support: At Wyo Stays, we believe in the power of community. In challenging economic times, we stand together, offering unwavering support and guidance to our clients.

Analyzing the Impact of Short-Term Rentals in Sheridan County

As a leading property management company, Wyo Stays is keenly aware of the dynamics affecting our local real estate market, especially in the context of short-term rentals. The Sheridan Press article paints a detailed picture of the evolving rental landscape in Sheridan County, highlighting several key factors:

Rapid Growth in Short-Term Rentals: From just about 35 properties in 2018 to a peak of 222 in 2023, short-term rentals have seen a substantial increase. Wyo Stays recognizes this trend as an opportunity for property owners to maximize their investments while contributing positively to the local tourism economy.

Diverse Impacts Across Localities: Each area within Sheridan County, from Sheridan to Big Horn, has experienced unique changes in short-term rental numbers and occupancy rates. Wyo Stays utilizes this nuanced understanding to tailor property management strategies that suit each specific locality.

Housing Market Dynamics: With the average home price and median rent significantly rising in recent years, Wyo Stays is committed to finding a balance. We ensure that properties under our management are priced fairly, maintaining a healthy balance between profitability for owners and affordability for renters.

Economic and Demographic Shifts: Acknowledging factors like the rise in remote workers and changes in population, Wyo Stays adapts its strategies to meet the evolving needs of both property owners and renters.

The Balance Between Short-term and Long-term Rentals: Understanding the importance of maintaining a healthy mix of rental options, Wyo Stays actively works to ensure that the community's needs for long-term rentals are met, even as we capitalize on the growing demand for short-term rentals.

Government Policy and Market Regulation: In light of discussions around potential government interventions in the short-term rental market, Wyo Stays remains vigilant and prepared to adapt to any new regulations, ensuring compliance and continued success for our clients.

Investment Property Insights: For investment properties, Wyo Stays offers expert advice on balancing rental income with mortgage payments, property appreciation, and market trends, ensuring that our clients make informed decisions.


Wyo Stays is not just a property management company; we are a dynamic partner in navigating the complexities of the Sheridan County rental market. Our expertise and proactive approach allow us to optimize property investments, support the local economy, and contribute to a vibrant community.


Looking Ahead

As the rental landscape evolves, so do we. Our commitment is to provide unparalleled service, ensuring your real estate investments not only endure but thrive, regardless of market conditions.

Closing Remarks

We want to extend our deepest gratitude to all our clients. Your trust in us fuels our dedication. Together, we navigate these times, not just as a company and clients, but as a community.

Stay informed, stay prosperous, and remember, Wyo Stays is here for you, through every season.


Wyo Stays - Sheridan Wyoming Property Management
By Dalton Goodyear November 14, 2024
Discover how Property Management Benefits Wyoming can enhance your rental investment with expert care, higher returns, and peace of mind for homeowners.
Discover key strategies for tenant screening in Wyoming to secure reliable renters and enhance
By Dalton Goodyear November 12, 2024
Discover key strategies for tenant screening in Wyoming to secure reliable renters and enhance your rental management success. Get practical application tips!
Discover key insights into the Sheridan Wyoming Rental Market 2024, including price trends, demand
By Dalton Goodyear November 12, 2024
Discover key insights into the Sheridan Rental Market 2024, including price trends, demand fluctuations, and investment potential in Wyoming.
Sheridan Wyo Rodeo 2025 - Stay with Wyo Stays, Partner With Wyo Stays
By Dalton Goodyear October 27, 2024
How Local Events Like the Sheridan Wyo Rodeo Impact Your Rental Income
March 12, 2024
Discover the most beautiful lakes in the Bighorn Mountains of Wyoming, perfect for any getaway. Whether you're seeking a romantic retreat or an action-packed adventure, our guide to the Bighorns' favorite lakes offers something for everyone. Explore serene waters, breathtaking landscapes, and a plethora of activities.
March 12, 2024
Explore the breathtaking beauty and thrilling adventures of the Bighorn Mountains in Sheridan, Wyoming. From scenic hikes and ATV rides to fishing and guided tours, find out why this is your next must-visit destination for both relaxation and adventure. Dive into our comprehensive guide for all the top activities and experiences.
March 1, 2024
As the frosty blanket of winter begins to lift, Sheridan, Wyoming, transitions into a landscape brimming with the promise of spring. February's chilly embrace brought the quintessential winter weather to our doorstep, setting the stage for a season of beauty, adventure, and serene escapes. Amidst this seasonal shift, Wyo Stays has emerged as a beacon of hospitality, significantly outperforming the local short-term rental market with an impressive 53% occupancy rate, compared to the local average of 28%. This achievement not only highlights our dedication to excellence but also our commitment to ensuring every guest enjoys an exceptional stay, no matter the season. Here's your ultimate guide to making the most of winter's end in Sheridan, with top to-dos that promise an unforgettable experience.
March 1, 2024
Discover how to maximize your real estate investment in Sheridan, Wyoming with Wyo Stays. Explore our expert guide on thriving in the local market, from vacation rentals to long-term investments, and learn why partnering with Wyo Stays means unlocking the full potential of your property. Join us for unparalleled property management solutions and become part of Sheridan's growing real estate success story.
February 22, 2024
Transform your rental property challenges into success stories with Wyo Stays in Sheridan, Wyoming. From tenant issues to legal compliance, learn how our comprehensive property management services can make owning investment properties stress-free and profitable.
February 20, 2024
Discover the ultimate Airbnb hosting hot tips to transform your Sheridan, Wyoming rental into a guest favorite. Dive deep into strategies that boost occupancy, enhance guest experiences, and maximize earnings with Wyo Stays.
More Posts
Share by: